I love a themed restaurant. And I love horror. So, Poe’s Tavern has been on my bucket list for a good long while. I was so fan-girling on our visit!
In our class several other REALTORS told us which restaurants around town to try, and Poe’s came up for their hamburgers. Little did I realize, that was nearly all they had, but it was ok because they were really delicious and huge!
The interior is pretty darn cool. There is a long communal table in the middle of the restaurant with high stools and a scattering of booths and tables around the other dining areas. What struck me were the paintings of Poe on the wall and the gothic looking light fixtures hanging over those communal tables. Even the bathroom was wallpapered with pages out of Poe’s books while an eerie voice read excerpts from his book while you did your business.
We ordered cocktails, I had the Poe’s Punch which was fruity and refreshing! Not too strong.
For dinner I had the Black Cat burger with Cheddar cheese instead of the pimento cheese. The burger was served well done, per my instructions, and still remained juicy. The meat was perfectly seasoned all the way through, not just on the top of the burger. It was loaded with toppings: bacon, drunken chili, cheese, lettuce, tomato..I could barely fit it in my mouth! It was so good!
If you like a themed restaurant that does a great burger, this place is for you.